A Place You Should Know: Sam Kee Building

Built in 1913, the Sam Kee Building at Pender and Carrall is celebrated for its architectural ingenuity, its cultural significance to the Chinese community and the impressive history of its namesake. It represents an important part of Vancouver’s history, and the pioneering spirit of its early citizens.

 

400-500 blocks of Carrall Street 1906. Sam Kee & Co. is the centre storefront in the group of three

400-500 blocks of Carrall Street 1906. Sam Kee & Co. is the centre storefront in the group of three

To begin with, Sam Kee was in fact a fictional person. The name was invented by Chang Toy, who operated Sam Kee Co. which resulted in him often being referred to as Sam Kee. Toy was a self-made man who came to Canada in 1874 as a labourer. His first business venture was a share in a laundry, later adding a small grocery, import/export services, steamship ticket sales, and eventually real estate. In 1888 Toy established the Sam Kee Co. which would become one of the largest merchant firms in Vancouver at the time. The success of the company would make Toy one of the wealthiest men in Chinatown with several still-standing buildings credited to him, including the 1906 Empress Rooms, now home to MacLeod’s Books at Pender and Richards.

 

Pender and Richards 1980s. Empress Rooms (now MacLeod's Books) pictured left.

Pender and Richards 1980s. Empress Rooms (now MacLeod’s Books) pictured left.

The Sam Kee Building is the most famous of Toy’s structures owing its unique architecture to a common theme in Chinatown’s history. Toy owned the piece of property at the corner of Carrall and Pender (then known as Dupont St.) until the municipal government made the decision to widen the road. A large portion of Toy’s property was expropriated, with conflicting reports as to how much he actually received in compensation. The consensus was that he was not properly compensated for the property value, and the incident is seen as representative of cultural injustices that were often experienced by early Chinese Canadians. Where most would expect Toy to sell the remaining 1.8m of land to the neighbouring property owner, Toy instead built a three-story commercial building.

 

Sam Kee Building, 1936.

Sam Kee Building, 1936.

The resulting Sam Kee building is widely acknowledged as the thinnest free standing building in the world, with a base of 1.5m that spreads to 1.8m at the bay windows (which project over the sidewalk). Designed by Bryan & Gillam, the building smartly uses the bay windows as well as the extended basement to make the most of the narrow footprint. The basement itself is significant, not only because it projects well under the street, but because it was utilized by the Chinese community for public baths and barber chairs, and unconfirmed rumours suggest it had been connected to other neighbouring basements via tunnel.

 

photo credit: www.visiblecity.com (posted May 2013.) Entrance to Chinatown. Sam Kee Building with Chow Insurance neon sign.

photo credit: www.thevisiblecity.com (posted May 2013.) Entrance to Chinatown. Sam Kee Building with Chow Insurance neon sign.

The Sam Kee Building is recognized as historically significant both on the City of Vancouver Heritage Register and the Canadian Historic Places Registry. It has been restored twice, once in 1966 and then again in 1986, and is currently under renovations in honour of its 100th birthday. The  Jack Chow Insurance neon sign that has been on the building since 1986 was one of the first to bring neon back to Chinatown, and is currently housed in the lobby at 1 East Pender.

Research:
Exploring Vancouver: The Essential Vancouver Guide. Harold Kalman, 1993.
Exploring Vancouver 2. Harold Kalman, 1974.
Building the West: Early Architects of Vancouver. Don Luxton, 2003.
The Greater Vancouver Book. Chuck Davis, 1997.
Vancouver the Way It Was. Michael Kluckner, 1984.

Images:
City of Vancouver Archives
Vancouver Public Library online resources
The Visible City. www.thevisiblecity.com May 2013.

2 comments

  1. Chang Toy was a shrewed businessman and he negotiated the sale of his original building at Carrall and Pender with the City. He asked for close to 70,000 and received 40,000 dollars which is what he wanted and was fair market value at the time. He was also well connected outside Chinatown and wasn’t someone you could, nor want to, take advantage of.

  2. Members of the public should be aware there is an proposal to significantly alter the entrance to this building, just one of its many interesting architectural features.

    It seems not even the few ‘heritage “A” buildings’ seem to protected from the development onslaught.

    Proposal found at: http://cfapp.vancouver.ca/planning_wa/index.cfm

    Alterations to Heritage Building
    Project 5565
    Project: Alterations to Heritage Building Status: Proposed
    Location: 8 W PENDER ST
    Zoning: HA-1
    Project Type: Addition / Alteration Department: Planning Department
    Application Date: 2011/08/25 No: DE415084
    City Contact: Mandy So 604-871-6080 mandy.so@vancouver.ca
    Applicant Contact: LISA KWAN SOREN RASMUSSEN ARCHITECTS INC 604 681 4292
    Description:
    Exterior and interior alteratons to this municipally designate heritage “A” building on all floors combining into one unit for this existing office tenant. Enclosure/addition at the exterior stairwell. Heritage restoration work also.

Comments are closed.